Week 5 - Summary + Thesis Draft 2

 Topic: Autodesk Revit

 Summary:

The webpage, “What is Revit? Why is Revit So Important?” from Q&A (n.d.) introduces Revit as Building Information Modeling (BIM) software used to create detailed 3D building models in digital format containing key building information including geometry, quantities, and properties of building components. Revit was developed by Autodesk and is used in the Architecture, Engineering, and Construction (AEC) industry by stakeholders such as developers, government agencies, engineers, architects, consultants, and construction professionals to plan, design, model, and manage building projects more efficiently. As mentioned in the webpage “What is Revit? Why is Revit So Important?” from Q&A (n.d.), Revit has many key functions and tools including 3D Modeling and Visualization allowing users to visualise buildings at any angle and perspective before it is constructed, Parametric Modeling allows interconnectivity between components in the models facilitating efficient and timely updating of building information, Multi-user Collaboration enables stakeholders to work together on the same model simultaneously and smoothly, Construction Simulation allows users to visualise and understand the construction processes from start to completion, and Clash Detection capability allows user to detect clashes and interferences between various building systems.

 Thesis:

It is clear that, as compared to the traditional 2D model such as Autocad, Revit has many functions that offer better design efficiency, accuracy as well as collaboration to end users including students.

 Support #1:

One such function is Revit’s 3D Design and Visualization. Revit’s 3D model in digital format displays the physical and spatial characteristics of a building, providing an interactive, detailed view of its structure and architecture. By doing so, it allows stakeholders to navigate and interact with the design in a virtual environment before construction enabling stakeholders to identify and resolve potential issues early. Project teams can therefore evaluate the design of the building more effectively and efficiently through a visual representation of the building (BIM Associates (n.d.)). On the other hand, 2D design uses two-dimensional drawings to represent buildings that typically include floor plans, sections, as well as elevations of buildings. This might pose a challenge for non-technical stakeholders to fully understand the design resulting in misinterpretations (Viatechnik (n.d.)).

 Support #2:

Another function is Revit’s Multi-user Collaboration. Revit’s shared platform allows different stakeholders to cooperate and work together on the same model anytime, anywhere in the world and in real- time. This promotes teamwork and ensures that the latest project information is shared amongst stakeholders and therefore reduces mistakes and misunderstandings (BIM Associates (n.d.)). In contrast, there is limited coordination in 2D Model. Each project team member creates its own sets of drawings and this can increase the chances of discrepancies between drawings resulting in clashes during construction. In addition, updating and revising 2D drawings across multiple disciplines is a tedious and time-consuming process and increases the likelihood of errors (Viatechnik (n.d.)).

 Support #3:

Clash Detection is an important function in which Revit posses to identify issues before construction begins. By integrating multiple disciplines into a single model, Revit automatically detects clashes. For example, a pipe running through a beam.  These conflicts can be resolved virtually, preventing costly rework during construction and minimises delays ensuring a smooth construction process ((BIM Associates (n.d.)). In comparison, 2D Model does not have the function to detect clashes automatically. When engineers discover a clash issue during construction, the design will need to be reconsidered and refined to avoid the clash, resulting in costly rework and work delays (United BIM (n.d.)).

Support #4:

Another function is Revit’s Construction Simulation which enhances construction project management. This 4D simulation in Revit enables the visualization and analysis of construction phases directly within the software. With this tool, project teams can simulate the entire construction process and lifecycle from start to completion, anticipate potential challenges, and optimize resource allocation. This improves project management and provides a clearer understanding of project phases, construction timelines as well as milestones. In contrast, Autocad is unable to generate construction simulations (Biblus (n.d.)).

 Counterargument:

Some users prefer to use Autocad as Revit has a steeper learning curve, especially for beginners who are new to BIM software and it will take longer time and training for Revit’s users to understand the BIM concepts and master the advanced functions before it can be used efficiently. In terms of hardware and resources, Revit requires robust hardware to run, whereas Autocad has less demanding system requirements which make it accessible on more computer devices (Autocadeverything (n.d.)).  

 Conclusion:

In conclusion, the capabilities and functions of Revit results in better building design efficiency, accuracy as well as collaboration amongst project stakeholders, as compared to the traditional 2D Model.

 References:

Q&A (n.d.).What is Revit? Why is Revit So Important? https://qnaengine.com/what-is-revit/

BIM Associates (n.d.). What is the BIM Model: A Comprehensive Guide to Building Information Modelling. https://www.bimassociates.com/blog/understanding-bim-model/

 Viatechnik (n.d.). Traditional 2D-Based Construction Drawings vs. BIM Modeling: Is it Time for an Upgrade? https://www.viatechnik.com/insights/blog/traditional-2d-construction-design-vs-bim/

 United BIM (n.d.). Clash Detection in BIM-Process, Benefits and Future Scope. https://www.united-bim.com/what-is-clash-detection-in-bim-process-benefits-and-future-scope-in-modern-day-aec-industry/

 Biblus (n.d.). 4D Simulation in Revit: How to Transform Time and Cost Management with BIM. https://biblus.accasoftware.com/en/4d-simulation-in-revit-how-to-transform-time-and-cost-management-with-bim/

Autocadeverything (n.d.). https://autocadeverything.com/autocad-vs-revit/#advantages-of-auto-cad


Comments

  1. Brad BlackstoneFebruary 7, 2025 at 10:01 PM

    There's too much use of ChatGPT in the summary. Can't you find the original sources of info (as listed in the reference list)? Use the gAI to source info, but don't rely on it exclusively.

    For your thesis and supports:


    You do have an explicit set of controlling ideas in your thesis: ...has many functions and tools that offer better design efficiency, accuracy and collaboration to end users including students.

    But your supporting paragraphs don't fully align so clearly with these key points. You mention
    1. One such function is Revit’s 3D Design and Visualization. (ok)
    2. Another advantage of using Revit instead of 2D Model is Revit’s capabilities for Multi-user Collaboration and Coordination. (huh?)

    --- Your first support paragraph is about a function, true, but the second is about an advantage?
    This doesn't make sense structurally.

    3. Clash Detection capabilities is ANOTHER of the important functions which Revit possess to identify issues before construction begin. (ok)


    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Nic Voon LeiFebruary 7, 2025 at 11:21 PM

      Dear Professor

      Thank you for your comments. I will go through this draft 2 again as soon as possible and make changes to it.

      Best Regards

      Nic Voon

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Week 1 Blogpost

Task 3: The Importance of communication skills for engineers  "Developing excellent communication skills is absolutely essential to effective leadership. The leader must be able to share knowledge and ideas to transmit a sense of urgency and enthusiasm to others. If a leader can't get a message across clearly and motivate others to act on it, then having a message doesn't even matter." Gilbert Amelio, former President and CEO of National Semiconductor Corp Excellent communication skills are absolute essential to effective leadership. This is especially true in build environment industry. The leader of an engineering or construction firm needs to communicate effectively to all stakeholders such as architects, engineers, sub-contractrors, workers, etc., and motivate them to ensure smooth execution and successful completion of a project. The leader needs to convey clearly important messages such as project objectives and requirements, project timelines and milestones, ch...
Read more

Formal email to Professor

Dear Professor Blackstone, I trust you had a great weekend. My name is Nic Voon and I am one of your students in the Critical Thinking and Communication class this trimester. I would like to introduce myself and let you know more about my background, communication strengths and weaknesses, specific goals of this module and what differentiates me from others. I graduated with a Diploma in Civil Engineering from BCA Academy in April 2022. After spending two years in the National Service, I chose to further my studies in Bachelors in Civil Engineering with SIT University in September 2024 as I always find construction and engineering interesting and challenging. Since young, I was fascinated with the skyscraper in Singapore and wondered how all these high-rise buildings were built from scratch. In addition, my father is a general manager of a reputable construction company in Singapore and he always shared with me numerous technical challenges he faced in his projects and how his teams th...
Read more

Factors Affecting My University Studies - Critical Thinking and Reflection

Problem Scenario: Revision for Modules by Modules Ideal Commit fully during my revision in the lecture notes then to the tutorials. Reality(gap) I am always searching for interesting places to visit rather than to study. Causes/Conditions As old age catches up, I often lose interest in university studies. Effects/Results Lack of sleep and time preparing for tests and exams which causes last minute revision. Goal Start revising after every lecture and tutorial lessons everyday once I get home. Possible change Switch off my phone and put it away. Testing the hypothesis > solution After school, try to go to quiet environment such as starbucks or coffeebean to start revision modules by modules. Outcome of change Able to finish my revision for lecture notes exercises and tutorials early on. This would help me to finish ...
Read more